Laurent Menut - Mineral dust modelling
My research focuses on modeling mineral aerosols for emission, transport and deposition. Modeling developments are integrated into each version of the CHIMERE model. The various developments are described below, from newest to oldest. For studies in which I am first author, the abstract is presented.
-
Menut, L., Variability and combination as ensemble of mineral dust forecast during the 2021 CADDIWA experiment, Geosci. Model Dev., 16, 4265-4281,
, 2023.
As operational support to define the Clouds-Atmospheric Dynamics-Dust Interactions in West Africa (CADDIWA) field campaign which took place in the Cape Verde area, the coupled regional model WRF-CHIMERE is deployed in forecast mode during the summer 2021. The simulation domain covers West Africa and the eastern Atlantic and allows the modeling of dust emissions and their transport to the Atlantic. On this route, we find Cape Verde, which was used as a base for measurements during the CADDIWA campaign. Meteorological variables and mineral dust concentrations are forecasted on a horizontal grid with a 30 km resolution and from the surface to 200 hPa. For a given day D, simulations are initialized from D-1 analyses and run for 4 d until D+4, yielding up to six available simulations on a given day. For each day, we thus have six different calculations, with better precision expected the closer we get to the analysis (lead D-1). In this study, a quantification of the forecast variability of wind, temperature, precipitation and mineral dust concentrations according to the modeled lead is presented. It is shown that the forecast quality does not decrease with time, and the high variability observed on some days for some variables (wind, temperature) does not explain the behavior of other dependent and downwind variables (mineral dust concentrations). A new method is also tested to create an ensemble without perturbing input data, but considering six forecast leads available for each date as members of an ensemble forecast. It has been shown that this new forecast based on this ensemble is able to give better results for two AErosol RObotic NETwork (AERONET) stations than the four available for aerosol optical depth observations. This could open the door to further testing with more complex operational systems.
-
Leung D.M., J.F. Kok, L.Li, N.M. Mahowald, C.Prigent, G.S. Okin, M.R. Klose, C.Pérez Garcia-Pando, L.Menut, D.M.Lawrence, and M.Chamecki, A new process-based and scale-respecting desert dust emission scheme for global climate models I: description and evaluations against inverse modeling emissions,
, Atmos. Chem. Phys., 23, 6487-6523, https://doi.org/10.5194/acp-23-6487-2023, 2023.
- Menut L., G.Siour, B.Bessagnet, A.Cholakian, R.Pennel and S.Mailler, Impact of wildfires on mineral dust emissions in Europe, Journal of Geophysical Research Atmospheres, 127, e2022JD037395. https://doi.org/10.1029/2022JD037395,
Mineral dust emissions mainly depend on soil erodibility and near-surface wind speeds. During
biomass burning episodes, pyroconvection locally generates high surface wind speed and non-desert surfaces
(such as forest and shrubs) are partially replaced by barren soil. These effects may induce additional mineral
dust emission. However, they are generally not taken into account in chemistry-transport models since the
biomass burning and mineral dust emissions are usually considered as independent processes. This may lead
to an underestimation of the mineral dust emissions and therefore of the transported concentrations. In this
study, this link is added in the CHIMERE chemistry-transport model. The summer of 2021 is modeled over
Europe using the coupled WRF-CHIMERE system. Simulations with and without the link between emission
processes are performed. Results are compared to observations such as surface measurements of ozone and
particulate matter by EEA and aerosol optical depth by AERONET. With more emitted mineral dust, an effect
is found on the whole meteorological and chemical system: wind, temperature, cloud, gas (such as ozone with
a few ppb changes) and aerosol concentrations are changed. The effect does not appear to be very important but
significant enough to have to be taken into account in future modeling.
- Menut, L., Siour, G., Bessagnet, B., Couvidat, F., Journet, E., Balkanski, Y., and Desboeufs, K.: Modelling the mineralogical composition and solubility of mineral dust in the Mediterranean area with CHIMERE 2017r4, Geosci. Model Dev., 13, 2051-2071,
, 2020
Modelling of mineral dust is often done using one single mean species. But for biogeochemical studies, it could be useful to access to a more detailed information on differentiated mineral species and the associated chemical composition. Differentiating between mineral species would also induce different optical properties and densities and then different radiative impact, transport and deposition. In this study, the mineralogical differentiation is implemented in the CHIMERE regional chemistry-transport model, by using global databases. The results show that this implementation does not change the results much in terms of aerosol optical depth, surface concentrations and deposition fluxes. But the information on mineralogy, with a high spatial (a few kilometres) and temporal (1 h) resolution, is now available and is ready to be used for future biogeochemical studies.
- Menut, L., 2018: Modeling of Mineral Dust Emissions with a Weibull Wind Speed Distribution Including Subgrid-Scale Orography Variance. J. Atmos. Oceanic Technol., 35, 1221-1236, https://doi.org/10.1175/JTECH-D-17-0173.1,
The modeling of mineral dust emissons requires a fine knowledge of the wind speed close to the surface. In
regional and global models, Weibull distributions are often used to better represent the subgrid scale variability of the wind speed. This distribution mainly depends on a k parameter, itself currently parameterized as a
function of the wind speed value. In this study, we propose to add the potential impact of the orography
variance in the wind speed distribution by changing the k parameter value. Academic test cases are designed
to estimate the parameters of the scheme. A realistic test case is performed over a large domain ecompassing
the northern part of Africa and Europe and for the period of 1st January to 1st May 2012. The simulations’s
results are compared to PM10 surface concentations and AERONET Aerosol Optical Depth and Aerosol Size
Distribution. We show that with the orography variance, the simulations results are closr to the ones without,
showing this additional variability is not the main driver of possible errors in mineral dust modeling.
- Bessagnet B., L.Menut, A.Colette, F.Couvidat, M.Dan, S.Mailler, L.Létinois, V.Pont, L.Rouil, 2017, An evaluation of the CHIMERE chemistry transport model to simulate dust outbreaks across the north Hemisphere in March 2014, Atmospheres,
-
Beegum S.N., I.Gherboudj, N.Chaouch, F.Couvidat, L.Menut, and H.Ghedira, 2016, Simulating Aerosols over Arabian Peninsula with CHIMERE: Sensitivity to soil, surface parameters and anthropogenic emission inventories, Atmospheric Environment, 128:185-197,
.
-
Hourdin F., M. Gueye, F. B. Diallo, J.-L. Dufresne, L. Menut, B. Marticorena, G. Siour, and F. Guichard, 2015, Parametrization of convective transport in the boundary layer and its impact on the representation of diurnal cycle of wind and dust emissions, Atmos. Chem. Phys., 15, 6775-6788, doi:10.5194/acp-15-6775-2015,
- Haustein K., R. Washington, J. King, D. Thomas, G. Wiggs, and L. Menut, Testing the performance of state-of-the-art dust emission schemes using DO4Models field data, Geosci. Model Dev., 8, 341-362, doi:10.5194/gmd-8-341-2015, 2015,
- Evan A., S.Fiedler, C.Zhao, L.Menut, K.Schepanski, C.Flamant and O.Doherty, 2015, Derivation of an Observation-Based Map of North African Dust Emission, Aeolian Research, 16, 153-162, 10.1016/j.aeolia.2015.01.001,
- Menut L., C.Perez Garcia-Pando, K.Haustein, B.Bessagnet, C.Prigent and S.Alfaro, 2013, Relative impact of roughness and soil texture on mineral dust emission fluxes modeling, Journal of Geophysical Research Atmospheres, 118, 6505-6520, doi:10.1002/jgrd.50313,
.
Dust production models (DPM) used to estimate vertical fluxes of mineral dust
aerosols over arid regions need accurate data on soil and surface properties. The
Laboratoire Inter-Universitaire des Systemes Atmospheriques (LISA) data set was
developed for Northern Africa, the Middle East, and East Asia. This regional data set was
built through dedicated field campaigns and include, among others, the aerodynamic
roughness length, the smooth roughness length of the erodible fraction of the surface, and
the dry (undisturbed) soil size distribution. Recently, satellite-derived roughness length
and high-resolution soil texture data sets at the global scale have emerged and provide the
opportunity for the use of advanced schemes in global models. This paper analyzes the
behavior of the ERS satellite-derived global roughness length and the State Soil
Geographic data base-Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations
(STATSGO-FAO) soil texture data set (based on wet techniques) using an advanced DPM
in comparison to the LISA data set over Northern Africa and the Middle East. We explore
the sensitivity of the drag partition scheme (a critical component of the DPM) and of the
dust vertical fluxes (intensity and spatial patterns) to the roughness length and soil texture
data sets. We also compare the use of the drag partition scheme to a widely used
preferential source approach in global models. Idealized experiments with prescribed
wind speeds show that the ERS and STATSGO-FAO data sets provide realistic spatial
patterns of dust emission and friction velocity thresholds in the region. Finally, we
evaluate a dust transport model for the period of March to July 2011 with observed
aerosol optical depths from Aerosol Robotic Network sites. Results show that ERS and
STATSGO-FAO provide realistic simulations in the region.
- Menut L., O.Masson, B.Bessagnet, 2009,Contribution of Saharan dust on radionuclides aerosols activity levels in Europe? The 21-22 February 2004 case study, J. Geophys. Res., 114, D16202, doi:10.1029/2009JD011767.
In February 2004, a spectacular dust event was observed in the south of France.
Associated with huge particulate matter deposition, unusual 137Cs concentrations were
found in samples. Using the transport model CHIMERE-DUST, we first show that these
dust aerosols came from North Africa. More precisely, the question is whether this
sudden increase of measured 137Cs concentrations was due to a huge amount of dust over a
large region (with an usual radionuclide content) or due to an import of more concentrated
air masses over a limited area. This question is connected to the open debate about the
contribution of 137Cs concentrations in Europe from ‘‘Gerboise’’ sites, where former
French nuclear tests in the 1960s were performed. With the model in scenario mode, this
study attempts to track down 137Cs concentrations recorded in the south of France. To
quantify the origin and percentage of dust originating from North Africa to the south of
France, three simulations are performed: (1) with the complete dust emissions inventory of
Africa, (2) with only emissions in the eastern Maghreb, and (3) only considering the
Gerboise sites. It is showed that the majority (80%) of the dust was coming from eastern
Maghreb, but only 0.7% of the African emissions were from Gerboise, leading to 1–5% of
the concentrations recorded in the south of France for the day of the peak.
- Vuolo M.R., H.Chepfer, L.Menut and G.Cesana, 2009, Comparison of mineral dust layers vertical structures modelled with CHIMERE-DUST and observed with the CALIOP lidar, Journal of Geophysical Research - Atmospheres , Vol. 114, D09214, doi:10.1029/2008JD011219,
- Menut L., I. Chiapello and C. Moulin, 2009, Previsibility of mineral dust concentrations: The CHIMERE-DUST forecast during the first AMMA experiment dry season , Journal of Geophysical Research - Atmospheres, 114, D07202, doi:10.1029/2008JD010523,
The predictability of northern Africa dust events is assessed using daily numerical
forecast simulations for the next 3 days. The dust concentration fields, modeled with the
CHIMERE-DUST model, were first evaluated by comparison with both Aerosol Robotic
Network (AERONET) surface data and Ozone Monitoring Instrument (OMI) and
Spinning Enhanced Visible and Infrared Imager (SEVIRI) satellite measurements. The
accuracy and spread between measurements and simulations are discussed for the first
short observation period of the African Monsoon Multidisciplinary Analysis (AMMA)
experiment in western Africa, between January and March 2006. The predictability of dust
events was then estimated by comparing model results for different leads in a forecast
mode. The model performance was evaluated with respect to its capability to forecast the
surface wind speed, which is the key process for dust emission, and the transport of
mineral dust near source regions and toward remote areas. It is shown that forecast
emissions can vary up to 80% (close to the sources) but that the variability on forecasted
dust concentrations and optical thicknesses do not exceed 40% and 20%.
- Vuolo M.R., L.Menut and H.Chepfer, 2009, Impact of transport schemes accuracy on modelled dust concentrations variability, Journal of Atmospheric and Oceanic Technology, 26, p.1135-1143, doi:10.1175/2008JTECHA1197.1,
- Menut L., 2008, Sensitivity of hourly Saharan dust emissions to NCEP and ECMWF modeled wind speed Journal of Geophysical Research - Atmospheres, 113, D16201, doi:10.1029/2007JD009522,
The impact of atmospheric aerosol concentrations on climate remains uncertain. This
is due to the lack of understanding of the physical processes involved and also to
uncertainties on the data used to model them. In the case of modeled dust emissions, the
key parameters are the surface wind speed and the soil characteristics. Dust emissions are
issued from inhomogeneous land surfaces and depend on local changes in wind speed.
Nevertheless, their representation in models is crude since the local variability of the
emission is not taken into account due to the model resolution. This simplified physical
representation is problematic since the first emission process, saltation, is triggered by a
threshold on the wind speed value. For most model studies, the global meteorological
fields used are issued either from NCEP or ECMWF models, but the impact of the forcing
was never quantified. In this study, we examine the emission fluxes variability based on
the selected meteorological data set. The difference between the two emission fluxes
can reach a factor of 3. This bias is not systematic and is highly variable on the timescale of
an hour within different areas over western Africa. The impact of the sandblasting scheme is
also studied; the variation arising by using two different schemes do not exceed 20%.
- Bessagnet B., L.Menut, G.Aymoz, H.Chepfer and R.Vautard, 2008, Modelling dust emissions and transport within Europe: the Ukraine March 2007 event Journal of Geophysical Research - Atmospheres, 113, D15202, doi:10.1029/2007JD009541,
- Menut L., G.Forêt and G.Bergametti, 2007, Sensitivity of mineral dust concentrations to the model size distribution accuracy,
Journal of Geophysical Research, Atmospheres, 112, D10210, doi:10.1029/2006JD007766.
Evaluating the impacts of atmospheric dust on marine ecosystems and climate
requires the use of three-dimensional transport models including a size-resolved bins
scheme to describe the evolution of the particle size distribution. Recently, Foreˆt et al.
(2006) proposed an alternative size bins scheme to better account for the physical
size-dependent processes such as dry deposition. This paper evaluates the benefit of using
this new bin scheme in three-dimensional transport models. This is achieved by
performing a one-and-a-half month simulation with the CHIMERE-DUST model forced
by the Mesoscale Model, Version 5 (MM5)/National Center for Environmental Prediction
(NCEP) analysis fields, for an area covering the northern Atlantic Sea and the western
Africa. Compared to a reference run performed using a large number of size bins (40), our
results show that the size bins scheme proposed by Foreˆt et al. (2006) reduces at least by a
factor of 2 the numerical errors on the simulated concentrations compared to the
classical isolog bins scheme for the same number of size bins. However, with this new
bins scheme requiring to define the bins according to a dry deposition velocity
corresponding to a given friction velocity, we examine the errors associated to this
constraint.
- Forêt, G., G. Bergametti, F. Dulac, and L. Menut, 2006, An optimized particle size bin scheme for modeling mineral dust aerosol,
Journal of Geophysical Research, 111, D17310, doi:10.1029/2005JD006797,
- Menut L., C.Schmechtig and B.Marticorena, 2005, Sensitivity of the sandblasting fluxes calculations to the soil size distribution accuracy,
Journal of Atmospheric and Oceanic Technology, 22, No. 12, pages 1875-1884,
Atmospheric dust concentrations are very sensitive to the dust surface emissions that are mainly controlled by saltation and sandblasting processes. Thus, a correct modeling of concentrations directly depends
on mass flux parameterization accuracy. In 2001, Alfaro and Gomes proposed a whole set of parameterizations linking the dust flux to surface wind speed and soil characteristics. Their formulation is based on
the integration of elementary fluxes, discretized along a soil size distribution. But, because the sandblasting
is a threshold process, this discretization must be as fine as possible when the threshold acts. And because
this threshold depends on dynamic parameters, it is necessary to always integrate fluxes with a high
resolution. This leads to large numerical simulations. In this paper it is shown that it is possible to estimate
fluxes with a good accuracy by adding equations that are dedicated to better describing the sensitive parts
of the emission scheme.